Grandma Vivian/Great Grandma Sophie's Gefilte Fish

Grandma Vivian/Great Grandma Sophie's Gefilte Fish
Grandma Vivian/Great Grandma Sophie's Gefilte Fish
This is what I grew up on. I'm not sure what the 3rd fish mentioned is. It looks like "buffel or "buffee", so I'm substituting carp, since this is commonly used. My mom and grandma never, ever, ever, ever measured! It was all done by feel. The fact that she even wrote this down is quite the miracle! Special thanks to my Aunt Judy for sending me this treasure.
  • Preparing Time: 30 minutes
  • Total Time: 30 minutes
  • Served Person: 12
white meat free gluten free red meat free contains fish shellfish free contains eggs dairy free pescatarian
  • 2 t salt
  • 1 t sugar
  • 1/2 t pepper
  • 1/4 t sugar
  • 1 qt water
  • 2 1/2 lbs white fish (from big fish) filleted and groud
  • 1 lb pike filleted and ground
  • 1 lb carp (buffee? buffel?) filleted and ground
  • all fish heads, bones, skin
  • 4 large onions separated 1 - sliced, 3 ground with fish
  • 8-9 eggs 2 per pound
  • 3 t salt
  • 1 t white pepper
  • 6-9? t matzoh meal
  • Carbohydrate 15.7254431568756 g
  • Cholesterol 71.440798275 mg
  • Fat 6.1217834141477 g
  • Fiber 3.27909978987526 g
  • Protein 26.966387444887 g
  • Saturated Fat 1.00672052456245 g
  • Serving Size 1 1 Serving (334g)
  • Sodium 72.403880549188 mg
  • Sugar 12.4463433670003 g
  • Trans Fat 0.876275501632135 g
  • Calories 224 calories

1. Wash bones, head and skin well and make a layer of it on bottom of large pot. Add the first list of salt, pepper and sugar. 2. Add sliced onions and water and bring to boil over low flame. 3. Place ground fish in wooden bowl. Add salt, white pepper, sugar, 2 eggs, matzoh meal, reserved ground onions. 4. Chop together and add 2 more eggs, 3 more T matzoh meal, until eggs are used up. If too thin, add matzoh meal. 5. Form balls and place in boiling water. *This is not in the recipe, but they would reserve some of the skin to wrap some of the gefilte fish balls in - this was a favorite of my grandma and I. 6. Cover with cold water. Cover pot tightly. Bring to boil. 7. Reduce heat and cook 3 hours, shaking pot every 1/2 hour. Best served chilled the next day, with horseradish and a little sugar (or no sugar, if you prefer).